UPDATE:
I noticed something today which may be of use to diagnosing the problem.
Iv just finished from a gig and noticed that whilst I was playing, the sound coming out of the speakers sounded like it had an extremely fine 'transformer' effect applied to it. With the loud volume, it probably wasn't very noticeable to the crowd, but as a DJ it was hard to miss.
Also, adjusting the tempo had a direct impact on this. When the tempo was raised, the defect in the sound was more noticeable, however when the tempo is set to '0' the sound wasn't noticeable. This may be why trying to scratch quickly is an issue.
I'll try to get some content uploaded tomorrow for a better understanding.